A onesided message is one where only the speakers perspective is set forth. The persuasive effectiveness of message sidedness one versus two sided messages and message structure was assessed in the context of a personal selling appeal for a new home computer to an unfamiliar target audience. First, the study provides a summary of findings of the persuasive impact of twosided advertising. A group of scientists presents data showing that a certain car company produces more pollution than any other company. Social influence and persuasion civil service india. According to a study published in the journal of personality and social psychology, individuals who were led to believe that they had thought a lot about a twosided message felt more certain about the resulting attitude than people who were led to believe that they had thought only a little about the same message. Find books like persuasion from the worlds largest community of readers. Cognitive processing of one and twosided persuasive. It attempts to illuminate the diverse, intriguing, and complex effects that message factors have on attitudes. You must master the art of speaking persuasively if you hope to generate the outcomes you want. Onesided messages are supportive messages to strengthen existing attitudes, but with no mention of counterpositions. Results showed that readers judged experts who communicated more consensusoriented by taking a twosided stance to be more trustworthy.
Usually the speaker will begin their persuasive speech by speaking in favor about the issue in which they hope to persuade. The psychology of persuasion as one of the most important books hes read. Chapter 7 of persuasive communication summarized the academic research concerning one and two sided messages. Information was presented in either a onesided each expert holds one position. One sided messages are supportive messages to strengthen existing attitudes, but with no mention of counterpositions. Oxford university press usa publishes scholarly works in all academic disciplines, bibles, music, childrens books, business books, dictionaries, reference books, journals, text books and more. By investigating specific advertising techniques i. First, the study provides a summary of findings of the persuasive impact of two sided advertising. It is compared with a twosided message, that primarily advocates one side but additionally recognizes, and at times, rejects, the other side pertaining to an issue. Mcguire contended that by exposing individuals to a persuasive message that contains weakened arguments against an established attitude e.
What is usually used is a flavor of honesty that strengthens the sales pitch. Perloff speaks to students in a style that is engaging and informational, explaining key theories and research as well as providing timely and relevant examples. The research suggests that as long as the twosided message actually refutes the opposition some weak twosided messages in these studies mentioned the opposition but didnt refute or attack the other side, twosided messages are more persuasive than onesided messages. Choose from used and new textbooks or get instant access with etextbooks and digital materials.
The persuasive effectiveness of message sidedness one versus twosided messages and message structure was assessed in the context of a personal selling appeal for a new home computer to an unfamiliar target audience. A onesided message was defined as a message presenting only those arguments in favor of the conclusion advocated by the communicator. An integrative framework for understanding twosided persuasion. A two sided message for a service bureau might acknowledge that a competitor is located closer to the prospect and then assert that proximity is irrelevant if the service bureau is doing a good job. Further, it was hypothesized that this effect would be significantly more pronounced for ss receiving a onesided message arguing in favor of the topic than it would for ss receiving either a onesided message arguing against the topic or a twosided. The list is designed to be particularly helpful for marketers, entrepreneurs and. Secondly, using regression analysis, the influence of message structure, marketer, and receiver variables on the persuasive impact of twosided messages is tested. But the best reason to use a twosided argument is that it has been. Simple recognition of opposing arguments, without including refutation of them, is the least effective technique for persuading the jury.
The first section introduces message structure, helping students appreciate the impact of onesided versus twosided messages, and conclusion drawing on attitudes. A two sided message was defined as a message including both the arguments in favor of and opposed to the conclusion. As the authors say, empirically, the order of the most effective messages should be twosided with refutation, onesided, and twosided with no refutation. Understanding how your audience operates is essential for successful marketing and brand strategies and all. One sided messages are frequently seen in political campaigns when a candidate denigrates his or her opponent through. If not, they will switch off and fail to process it. The theory has not yet been applied in a twosided persuasion context, but is recommended by crowley and hoyer 1994 as a plausible explanation to conflicting findings of previous studies e.
Analyzing experimental data n 141 we find that onesided satire offered by the onion ironically claiming that global warming is a hoax encourages viewers to engage in greater message elaboration and counterarguing. Twosided persuasion consists of a message that pro. Finally, the crucial problem of the neteffect of source credibility and the amount of negative information on attitudes toward the brand is investigated. Charlotte perkins gilman, human work, 1904 introduction many of lifes powers can either harm or help us. Subjects who initially agreed with the argument presented were more persuaded by the one sided message. Apr 07, 20 a message consisting of arguments which solely advocate one side of a problem. A refutational twosided message refutes the opposing arguments in the message eisend 2007. This chapter focuses on the centerpiece of persuasion. You might be reluctant to make your audience aware of other viewpoints for fear you could lose their. Are onesided or twosided arguments more persuasive.
Jul 26, 2011 are one sided or two sided arguments more persuasive. In the third edition, crisp new examples, both classic and contemporary, vivify the writing and illustrate just how consequential persuasion is in the sciences, politics, health, and the law. A few notable studies applied twosided messages to health. It is compared with a two sided message, that primarily advocates one side but additionally recognizes, and at times, rejects, the other side pertaining to an issue. If an audience is not aware of the opposing argument or already agrees with the message, twosided appeals are not necessary. The persuasive impact of twosided selling appeals for an. Everyday we are bombarded with messagesfrom people who wish to influence our behavior and attitudes. This research aims to assess whether the persuasion of a specific type of message is influenced by need for cognition nfc and time pressure. Whether a persuasive message is onesided or twosided depends on the. Best persuasion books books that help anyone selling anything do it more effectively.
When an audience is hostile toward your claim, be sure to present a twosided message. The dynamics of persuasion resources chapter 7 routledge. Studies regarding message sidedness and persuasion indicate that sidedness effects are moderated by the type of twosided message employed, but do not. Cognitive processing of one and twosided persuasive messages jerold l. Nov 07, 2017 with any persuasive measure, audience matters. Onesided messages are frequently seen in political campaigns when a candidate denigrates his or her opponent through. Twosided refutational messages are about 20 percent more persuasive than onesided messages, and onesided messages are about 20 percent more persuasive than twosided nonrefutational messages. Understanding how your audience operates is essential for successful marketing and brand strategies and all communication for that matter. Subjects who initially agreed with the argument presented were more persuaded by the onesided message. The dynamics of persuasion has been a staple resource for teaching persuasion for nearly two decades. Two sided messages although a speaker will show that they favor a certain position, heshe will also acknowledge the competitor or opposing viewpoint. For vegans, it is likely that their nonvegan audience is unfamiliar with the antispeciesist claimsmaking and would benefit from a twosided appeal. The theory of inoculation was derived from previous research studying onesided and twosided messages.
The first section introduces message structure, helping students appreciate the impact of onesided versus twosided messages, and conclusion drawing on. For vegans, it is likely that their nonvegan audience is unfamiliar with the antispeciesist claimsmaking and would benefit from a two sided appeal. When audiences were initially neutral, there was no significant difference in the effectiveness of one and twosided messages mean r. The theory has not yet been applied in a two sided persuasion context, but is recommended by crowley and hoyer 1994 as a plausible explanation to conflicting findings of previous studies e. A onesided speech offers only arguments for your claim while a twosided speech takes into account opposing ideas and proposals and then answers them. Subjects who disagreed with the argument presented were more persuaded by the two sided message. A twosided message was defined as a message including both the arguments in favor of and opposed to the conclusion. To swallow and follow, whether old doctrine or new propaganda, is a weakness still dominating the human mind. Subjects who disagreed with the argument presented were more persuaded by the twosided message.
Secondly, using regression analysis, the influence of message structure, marketer, and receiver variables on the persuasive impact of two sided messages is tested. The 336 undergraduates participated in a 2 message sidedness. Mar 16, 2017 strategy 5 books that will help you persuade anybody of anything an unusual book list that will teach you how to get hordes of followers. Onesided messages were significantly more persuasive than twosidedmessages when audiences were initially favorable mean r. In the research literature on persuasion, this basic contrastignoring versus notignoring opposingargumentshascommonlybeencaptured in the distinction between a onesidedmessage which ignores opposing argu ments and a twosidedmessage which, while presenting supportive argu ments, also acknowledges opposing arguments. It describes the practical implications persuasive communication techniques offer to lawyers practicing. Contrary to some prior research, twosided appeals were found to be less, not more, effective in promoting seller. There are two ways to persuade people either using their thinking or using their feeling or gutfeeling. People who use their thinking to change their attitude would be highly motivated. Using humor to engage the public on climate change. Social influence is described as the change in persons behaviour, thoughts, feelings and attitudes that results from interaction with another individual in society. Later they will discuss opposing viewpoints or counterarguments. Social influence and persuasion are fundamental functions of communication.
The first section introduces message structure, helping students appreciate the impact of one sided versus two sided messages, and conclusion drawing on attitudes. Persuasion final at georgia state university studyblue. They found that the least persuasive messages were twosided with no. Some specific factors affecting attitude change journal of. He published books on marketing research and marketing. If an audience is not aware of the opposing argument or already agrees with the message, two sided appeals are not necessary. Metaanalysis comparing the persuasiveness of onesided. Persuasion canbe used to accomplish good as well as bad, though, in my paper i. Chapter 7 persuasion persuasion attitude psychology. Studies regarding message sidedness and persuasion indicate that sidedness effects are moderated by the type of two. Cognitive processing of one and twosided persuasive messages. Two sided messages were more effective with subjects with at least a high school education. A twosided message for a service bureau might acknowledge that a competitor is located closer to the prospect and then assert that proximity is irrelevant if the service bureau is doing a good job.
This is an ideal standalone textbook for an undergraduate class that seeks to show what is known about persuasion and how we have come to know it. A one sided message was defined as a message presenting only those arguments in favor of the conclusion advocated by the communicator. Aug 26, 2019 the research explores the differential impact of exposure to onesided vs. Feb 09, 2016 mcguire contended that by exposing individuals to a persuasive message that contains weakened arguments against an established attitude e. Introduction a speech can be well organized, with solid supporting materials, and still fail to persuade. Twosided messages were more effective with subjects with at least a high school education. Metaanalysis comparing the persuasiveness of onesided and. The theory of inoculation was derived from previous research studying one sided and two sided messages. Otto perceived persuasive message persuasive strategy pit bull. Chapter 17 persuasive speaking persuasion audience. Further, it was hypothesized that this effect would be significantly more pronounced for ss receiving a one sided message arguing in favor of the topic than it would for ss receiving either a one sided message arguing against the topic or a two sided, pro or con message. Persuasive communication that presents both sides of an argument. Thomas studies regarding message sidedness and persuasion indicate that sidedness effects are moderated by the type of twosided message employed, but do not indicate why various messages differ in persuasiveness. How to use 10 psychological theories to persuade people.
Jul 26, 2011 persuasion when you try to persuade people to accept your position on a divisive issue, including opposing opinions in your argument can make your message more persuasive. The research explores the differential impact of exposure to onesided vs. A number of time people are willing to devote to processing a persuasive message depends on the motivations of the listener. The most persuasive were those in which the speaker listed counterarguments and then refuted them. When you try to persuade people to accept your position on a divisive issue, including opposing opinions in your argument can make your message more persuasive. Twosided message research has often led to ambiguous findings due to several factors. Twosided nonrefutational messages present both sides of the argument without discrediting or arguing against counterpersuasive appeals.
530 953 633 36 132 1524 1390 173 1178 1516 1361 1513 921 759 1158 1386 121 999 1507 1419 84 836 1389 318 328 1469 618 1323 322 1483 1021 504 1097 1208 761 150 1492 680